Collision and comprehensive coverage only ever pay up to what your car is worth, minus the deductible. As the car ages, that ceiling falls every year while the premium usually doesn't. Enter your car's value and the two premiums from your policy to see which coverage still earns its keep โ and when it stops.
Collision and comprehensive pay the car's actual cash value, minus your deductible โ never more. A $4,500 car with a $1,000 collision deductible can return at most $3,500, however bad the crash. Meanwhile the premium for that coverage stays roughly the same as the car loses 10% to 15% of its value each year. At some point you're paying hundreds a year to protect a few thousand dollars.
The Insurance Information Institute's rule of thumb, cited by Kelley Blue Book: if your car is worth less than ten times the annual premium, the coverage may not be cost-effective. Run it separately for each coverage. Comprehensive โ theft, hail, flood, fire, a deer โ usually costs about half as much as collision, so it often stays worthwhile for several more years. Dropping collision alone is the most common first step.
Insurance loses money on average for the buyer; that's how insurers stay in business. You buy it for the year you can't absorb the loss. If wrecking the car tomorrow would leave you unable to get to work, keep the coverage until you've saved enough to replace the car. If you could buy another car with cash, the premium is mostly a fee for a risk you can already carry.
See how insurance fits with every other running cost in Is Full Coverage Worth It on an Older Car?